This is not the statue at the university. This one is in the Company’s Garden. Note the raised arm – he is pointing north and the caption reads: ‘Your hinterland is there’. His dream was to control the whole of Africa for the British Empire. Not half ambitious or greedy, much?

I’ve been engaging in the most delightful (not!) debates (and observing others) on Facebook  about the current debacle raging in Cape Town and Grahamstown. Briefly, students at the University of Cape Town are demanding that a statue of Cecil John Rhodes that stands large and dominant overlooking the playing fields should be destroyed because he was an imperialist racist who abused black labour to enrich himself. The detractors of this request are claiming that he gave his land to the city and one of many things built on that land is the university itself, as well as a scholarship founded with his fortune. The protests have spread to Grahamstown where the students want the name of the university there changed from Rhodes University.

There’s a whole lot more to it of course and it’s complicated, as are most similar issues in South Africa, but it has raised a level of consciousness on certain topics that I think is welcome.

There’s white privilege (a concept that many who benefit from it refuse to acknowledge), there’s ignorance of history (usually a choice by those who prefer denial), there’s racism, there’s theft of land from indigenous people, there’s the after-effects of colonialism, and much more. But what is quite revealing is how issues like this serve to bring racists out of under the rocks where they rightly belong. The issue is, of course, more about transformation than a statue but ignorance of history makes people think that black people in South Africa should just be happy they finally have the vote and should all ‘move on and forget the past’. Never mind that the worst of the past is still in their faces, day in and day out, such as the statue in question. Here’s a summary of the events of the past 3 weeks (with a photo of the UCT statue shrouded by students) and here are some quotes that show what a monster he was.

My favourite comment is this (from Africa is a Country):

“In calling for the statue to be removed then, activists are not only addressing the hidden divisions of labour that sustain academia on the backs of black bodies, they are critiquing the raced, classed an[d] gendered dimensions that shape access to education in South African society. Challenging whiteness at UCT is not to suggest that individual students are to blame for the absence of transformation, but to point out that millions of black people in this country find themselves in a position where even gazing upon the statue of Rhodes is a remote possibility. It is to point out that economic inequality remains heavily racialized and gendered, and in order to transform our universities there needs to be a greater recognition of the structural violence that black people continue to endure as they send their children off to dilapidated schools in far flung rural areas with few employment opportunities once they finish. There is a long history of student occupations setting off a chain reaction of social protest. Throughout history students have acted as catalysts of struggle, as they often feel the impacts of economic and political change most acutely. In South African history, they have also been the ones willing to take the risks required to advance emancipatory struggles. “

And my favourite #hashtag comment is: ” #‎RhodesMustFall exists precisely because of the type of people who think it is a protest about a statue.” If you don’t understand that then you don’t understand much at all.

I personally don’t believe the statue should be destroyed. It should be moved elsewhere and used, with other symbols, to explain and place colonialism and racism in its appropriate context. This could in fact be a perfect opportunity to contextualise the issues. Cape Town does not have an apartheid museum (something I deplore constantly and find hard to explain to tourists who don’t have the opportunity to see the one in Johannesburg) but this could be the perfect starting point for something similar in this city.

I know some people don’t like it when I write about issues like this but that’s too bad. It’s a reality of our daily life in South Africa and avoiding/denying it is your choice, not mine.

About Francoise Armour

I run a small touring company (Tours du Cap) at the bottom of Africa, to show visitors the beauty and vibrant culture of the country I have lived in since my parents brought me here from France as a child. I enjoy taking photos and wish I had learnt to do it properly. I enjoy writing but don't do enough of it. I enjoy walking in the mountains that surround me and I marvel over the views and the flowers and the amazing rock formations. I have a small, cute, clever, black dog of indeterminable breed, named Vida, who reminds me regularly that walking and getting out is not only for when tourists want it.

All feedback welcome, so share your thoughts please!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


A note to all accidental visitors:

I am not a photographer and do not claim to have any particular skills whatsoever in that department. I have enormous respect for those who can see the potential in a scene and can create a great photo. Good photography is an art, in my opinion.

I am just a happy snapper, I have no special lenses or accessories, my camera is very simple and it's usually best to leave the setting on auto.

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 81 other followers

The Best Ticher

EFL advice, tricks and tips for newbie teachers...

Nourish Your Soul

Live, Learn, Love & Grow!

Morsels of Gratitude

Trying to find the positive in a world where negative has become too comfortable

Tales from the African Bush

Brian Connell - Author

WordPress.com News

The latest news on WordPress.com and the WordPress community.

Trekking Across Gondwanaland

My long journey to Australia and back

A pic a day from the Cape

Snippets of my life, my city, and beyond

%d bloggers like this: